I would give it 5 stars but....
This is a replacement lounge cushion and the fit is perfect, the color is very nice - a navy, but more of a navy blue Jean color. There's plenty of CUSH in the cushion. Lol. My only complaint - there are only center ties to secure the cushion to the lounger. I would recommend to the manufacturer to add Velcro straps or additional ties to the top & bottom of the cushion.